Jade Fern Grove did the stars whisper on the day you were made?

"How can you be two things at once?" Esma asked, continuing to ride along the tracks of her own thoughts and ideas of the world. She could not understand, why would anyone name their children in names that had already been claimed by other beings - alive or inanimate. "Are you more of a dusty rose or a wolf then?" she asked next, still not understanding, how could a wolf be a flower at he same time. Dirty one too. 

"Riverclan has water everywhere," she remarked, finding it odd that one had to dig for it. "Why did you live in a place, where you had to dig for water?" she asked and the question reflected her own lack of experience with the outside world. She just could not picture, how could it be that the water would not be easily available. Found everywhere. 

"Yes," she nodded. "Do you?"